# I memo yakwaMicrosoft ngokuqeqeshwa kwe-AI ivele obala.

Published: 2026-09-18

Amafayela angacishiwe ecaleni leNew York Times v. OpenAI & Microsoft: I memo yomqondisi wakwaMicrosoft yangoJanuwari 2023 ibiza idatha yokuqeqesha i-AI "njengobugebengu obukhulu bokweba umsebenzi emlandweni wesintu", iCopilot yehlise ukuchofoza okudlula ku-Times ngo-93% (okwakhe "i-doom loop"), uNadella uthi okuqukethwe okukhokhelwayo kufanele kunikezwe ilayisense, inhloko yeChatGPT ibiza umkhiqizo "njengokufaka esikhundleni", futhi uGreg Brockman uphendule isigebengu sokudlula i-paywall ngaphendula "ah nice." Ngosuku olufanayo: I-OpenAI ikhipha i-Astra for Law (iku-54% ilungile kumgqugquzeli wezomthetho weVals). Kanye ne-ZCode elayisha yonke .git yakho ku-Aliyun ngekhiye kuphela i-Z.ai enakho, kanye ne-Hacktron efika kuma-repos angaphakathi e-OpenAI ngomklomelo ka-$6,500. Isinqumo: NEEDS REVIEW.

Canonical: https://thedailydiff.dev/zu/video/2026-09-18-theft-of-labor/

## Lokho okuhlanganiswa yile vidiyo

- NYT v. OpenAI/Microsoft ivele obala: "ubugebengu obukhulu bokweba umsebenzi emlandweni wesintu" (memo yakwaMicrosoft, Jan 2023); I-Copilot −93% ukuchofoza okudlulayo; amakhophi angu-91,692 emisebenzi yababamangali kudatha ephakathi nokuqeqesha; amakhasi angu-2M nytimes.com kwesinye isicezu se-Common Crawl; izaziso ze-copyright zisusiwe; uBrockman: "ah nice"
- Isexwayiso: izingcaphuno zivela encwadini ye-Times, imibukiso isavalwe; IJaji u-Alsup (Bartz v. Anthropic) lahlinzeka ukuthi ukuqeqesha ngezincwadi ezithengiwe kuwukusetshenziswa okufanele — I-Anthropic yakhokha u-$1.5B ngezigidi eziyi-7 ezebiwe
- I-OpenAI Astra for Law: I-GPT-6 Astra + inkomba yezomthetho engu-230M-URL; 54.0% vs 38.7% ku-Vals Legal Research Bench; uHarvey, uLegora, ama-plugin angu-26
- I-ZCode (Z.ai, GLM): Isifinyezo esibethelwe esingu-313 MB sendawo yokusebenzela yamafayela angu-42,411, 86.6% .git, ilayishwe ku-Aliyun OSS lapho ungena futhi ngaphambi kwayo yonke imiyalo; ikhiye le-RSA-OAEP liphethwe kuphela yi-Z.ai; izilungiselelo zokuguqula azikuvimbi
- I-Hacktron: libheif heap overflow → Discourse RCE → SSO misconfig → GitHub → OpenAI internal repos ngaphansi kwamahora angu-72; ukuxhaphazwa nguClaude Opus 5 (amahora angu-3); umkhankaso ngaphansi kuka-$3,000 kuma-token; umklomelo u-$6,500, ulungiswe cishe ngamahora angu-14

## Umbhalo obhaliwe ohunyushwe

Kuhunyushwe kusuka ekulandiseni kokuqala kwesiNgisi. Umsindo namazwibela atholakalayo alawulwa yi-YouTube.

0:00 NgoJanuwari 2023, umqondisi wakwaMicrosoft wabhala i-memo ebizwa ngokuthi inkampani yakhe yenza ubugebengu obukhulu bokweba umsebenzi emlandweni wesintu, futhi izolo inkantolo yenhlangano yenze ukuthi abanye bethu bakwazi ukukufunda. Le memo ingenye yezingcaphuno ezingacishiwe ecaleni leNew York Times vs. OpenAI kanye neMicrosoft, icala elizophela izinyanga ezintathu kulo Disemba. NgoLwesine olufanayo, i-OpenAI ikhiphe i-Astra for Law, imodeli yammeluleki bezomthetho, okuwukuqashwa okungahleliwe noma okuqine kakhulu. Namuhla ekuseni umthuthukisi ubambe i-ZCode, i-Z dot A I's coding agent,

0:29 ilayisha wonke umlando wakhe we-git efwini le-Alibaba ngekhiye kuphela i-Z dot A I elinayo. Futhi inkampani yezokuphepha yangena kuma-repository angaphakathi e-OpenAI ngokulayisha isithombe, okwa-OpenAI yakukhokhela izinkulungwane eziyisithupha namakhulu amahlanu amadola. Kule vidiyo: okushiwo amafayela, obani abathi ah nice kokuphulwa kwe-paywall, imodeli yomthetho elihlale lingalungile ngesigamu sesikhathi, okulayishwa yi-ZCode, nokuthi kungani ukuxhaphazwa okubhalwe yi-Claude kubiza ngaphansi kwemoto esetshenzisiwe. NgoLwesihlanu, Septhemba 18, futhi lokhu yiThe Daily Diff.

0:58 Ake siqale nge-memo. UBrent Hecht uhola isayensi esetshenzisiwe kwaMicrosoft, futhi ngoJanuwari 2023 wabiza idatha yokuqeqesha ubugebengu obumangalisayo obungakaze bubonwe. Ngemuva konyaka wabuya ngesethulo sama-slide: injini yokuphendula ye-Copilot yehlise ukuchofoza okudlula ku-Times ngokuze kube ngamaphesenti angamashumi ayisishiyagalolunye nantathu, akubiza ngokuthi i-doom loop: bulala abashicileli, futhi imodeli ayinakho okusha okufanele ikudle. Amazwi akhe: umkhiqizo wokugcina osongela izisekelo zezomnotho zabahlinzeki bawo

1:21 ababahlinzeki ababalulekile, indlela yenkampani yokusho ukuthi inyoka isithole umsila wayo. Bese kuba yimibuzo. USatya Nadella ufakazele kulo nyaka ukuthi noma yini ekhokhelwayo kufanele inikezwe ilayisense, futhi ukuthi ukube ubesazi ukuthi i-OpenAI iqeqeshe ngama-athikili akhokhelwayo ubezobenza baqeqeshe kabusha, okucabanga ukuthi akekho kwaMicrosoft ovule isethi yokuqeqesha abayinikwe, futhi ngokusho kwefayela elifanayo lelo kwakuyidatha yonke ye-GPT-3. UNick Turley, oqhuba iChatGPT, wakubiza ngokuthi usongo olukhulu kubashicileli, okungokwengxenye okuyikhono lokufaka esikhundleni. Futhi lapho umcwaningi

1:49 etshela uGreg Brockman ngokuphulwa kwe-paywall ukuze adlule ku-paywall ye-Times, umongameli we-OpenAI uphendule ngamagama amabili: ah nice. Onjiniyela futhi basuse izaziso ze-copyright kudatha ukuze imodeli ingazikhiphi, yingakho ususa inombolo ye-serial kubhayisikili. Isikali: amakhophi angaphezu kwamashumi ayisishiyagalolunye nanye ezinkulungwane zama-athikili abamangali kumasethi aphakathi nokuqeqesha kuphela, namakhasi e-Times ayizigidi ezimbili kusicezu esisodwa se-Common Crawl. Manje isiqephu esishiywa yi-headline.

2:15 Yonke ingcaphuno ivela encwadini ye-Times; imibukiso isavalwe, ngakho sifunda okuvelele kwabamangalelayo ngaphandle komongo. Futhi izinkantolo zivame ukuhambisana nokusetshenziswa okufanele: IJaji u-Alsup lagweba ngonyaka odlule ukuthi ukuqeqesha ngezincwadi ozikhokhele kungokomthetho, nakuba i-Anthropic isakhokhe ibhiliyoni elilodwa nesigamu ngezigidi eziyisikhombisa eyazeba. Ngakho umbuzo wezomthetho uvulekile. Ukuthi abantu abakwakha bacabanga ukuthi kwakuwubugebengu, kusukela izolo, cha.

2:41 Okunye okwenza ukwethulwa kwe-OpenAI ngoLwesine kube yisinqumo esinesibindi. I-Astra for Law ihlanganisa i-GPT-6 Astra, imodeli engiyishayele REVERT ngesonto eledlule ngemuva kokukhiqiza imigqa engamashumi ayisikhombisa nanhlanu ezinkulungwane zokungabi nalutho, enkombeni yosesho lwezomthetho yamakhasi ayizigidi ezingamakhulu amabili namashumi amathathu. Ku-benchmark yocwaningo lwezomthetho lwe-Vals AI idlula amaphesenti angamashumi amahlanu nane emibuzo, inyuka isuka kumashumi amathathu nesishiyagalolunye ngosesho olulula lwewebhu, okubizwa yi-OpenAI ngokuthuthuka okungamaphesenti angamashumi amane futhi ummeli angakubiza ngokuthi kungalungile cishe isigamu sesikhathi. Okuthunyelwe kubhulogi akuqukethe igama elithi ukukhohlisa.

3:14 I-Hacker News yathi: ingabe izokwazi ukuzimangalela, oku, uma kubhekwa isonto, yiyona yokuqala esetshenziswayo yangempela. Phakathi naleso sikhathi inkulumo yokweba umsebenzi ifinyelele kwi-laptop yakho. Umthuthukisi ogama lakhe lingu-ferstar uhlanze ifolda yakhe ye-ZCode, i-Z dot A I's desktop agent evaliwe yamamodeli e-GLM, futhi wathola ingobo yomlando ebethelwe engamakhulu amathathu neshumi nantathu megabyte yendawo yakhe yokusebenzela yezohwebo: amafayela angamashumi amane nambili ezinkulungwane, amaphesenti angamashumi ayisishiyagalombili nesikhombisa kuwo ayi-dot git directory, athunyelwa endaweni yokugcina izinto ye-Alibaba lapho ungena futhi ngaphambi kwayo yonke imiyalo.

3:42 Ingobo yomlando igoqwe ngekhiye yomphakathi esatshalaliswa iseva; ikhiye yangasese iphila kuphela efwini le-Z dot A I, ngakho i-ciphertext kudiski yakho ayifundeki kuwe. Umugqa wakhe: ikhiye iseva kuphela engayisebenzisa isebenza ngenjongo eyodwa kuphela. I-Z dot A I futhi yinkampani i-Anthropic eyasola ngokuhlanza uClaude, ngakho izisindo zivulekile futhi, ngokusobala, ne-repo yakho. Futhi okuhlekisayo, ngaphandle uma usebenza kwa-OpenAI. I-Hacktron ithole i-heap overflow ku-libheif, yayilayisha isithombe esenziwe

4:10 ku-community dot openai dot com, yathola ukwenziwa kwekhodi esithangamini, futhi yahamba nge-single sign-on engalungiswanga ngokuqinile ngokusebenzisa ukuhlanganiswa kwe-GitHub yangena kuma-repository angaphakathi e-OpenAI, ngaphansi kwamahora angamashumi ayisikhombisa nambili. Ukuqhuma kwabhalwa nguClaude: i-Opus 4.8 ayikwazanga ukunqoba i-address randomization, i-Opus 5 yakwenza kungakapheli amahora amathathu yakhishwa. Umkhankaso wonke ubize ngaphansi kwezinkulungwane ezintathu zamadola ngama-token. I-OpenAI yayilungisa ngamahora ayishumi nane futhi yakhokha izinkulungwane eziyisithupha namakhulu amahlanu amadola, ngakho ikhodi yomthombo yenkampani eyibhiliyoni yama-dollar yaba,

4:39 okwesikhashana, ibiza njengeCorolla esetshenzisiwe, ngosuku olufanayo abameli bayo bathi ukukopisha kuwukusetshenziswa okufanele. Uma ukhetha ukukufunda lokhu kunokungizwa ngikukho, i-diff ifika ebhokisini lakho leposi njalo ekuseni — mahhala ku-the daily diff dot dev, isixhumanisi esingezansi. Ngakho — isinqumo sanamuhla: sidinga ukubuyekezwa. Izingcaphuno zangempela, kodwa ziyizikhetho zabashushisi ezivela emibukisweni evaliwe, futhi ijaji elilodwa eliye lagweba lithi ukuqeqesha kuwukusetshenziswa okufanele kanti ubugebengu cha. Inkantolo inquma umthetho; i-memo isivele inqume izimiso zokuziphatha.

5:07 Bhalisa, chofoza insimbi, futhi ungitshele kumazwana uma ubuwuyishaya uphawu ngokuhlukile. Futhi lokho yi-diff yanamuhla. NginguNiko ovela kwa-Axrisi. Hlanganisa ngokuzibophezela.

## Imithombo

- [TechCrunch: Microsoft exec called AI scraping 'the largest theft of labor in human history'](https://techcrunch.com/2026/09/17/microsoft-exec-called-ai-scraping-the-largest-theft-of-labor-in-human-history-new-unredacted-filings-reveal/) — techcrunch.com
- [HN thread (605 pts)](https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=49752056) — news.ycombinator.com
- [Jason Kint on the unsealed motions](https://x.com/jason_kint/status/2100611139906228629) — x.com
- [Ed Newton-Rex](https://x.com/ednewtonrex/status/2100649215290466631) — x.com
- [Bartz v. Anthropic / $1.5B settlement (background)](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anthropic) — en.wikipedia.org
- [OpenAI: Introducing Astra for Law](https://openai.com/index/astra-for-law/) — openai.com
- [HN: Astra for Law (550 pts)](https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=49745940) — news.ycombinator.com
- [ferstar: ZCode silent workspace snapshot (original forensics)](https://blog.ferstar.org/en/posts/zcode-silent-workspace-snapshot/) — blog.ferstar.org
- [tokenstead write-up](https://tokenstead.ai/guides/zcode-silent-git-history-upload) — tokenstead.ai
- [ferstar on X](https://x.com/ferstar_org/status/2100805861002355154) — x.com
- [HN: ZCode uploads your Git history (226 pts)](https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=49752422) — news.ycombinator.com
- [Hacktron: Hacking OpenAI](https://www.hacktron.ai/blog/hacking-openai) — www.hacktron.ai
- [HN: Hacktron (406 pts)](https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=49749656) — news.ycombinator.com